PunchPro vs Workyard

PunchPro vs Workyard: Which Workforce Management Platform Is Better for Growing Field Teams?

Compare pricing, scheduling, PTO management, GPS tracking, job costing, payroll flexibility, and workforce management features to determine which platform is right for your team.

Start Free Trial → See the full comparison

No credit card required. Get started in minutes.

Construction worker wearing a PunchPro hard hat

The quick verdict

Two strong tools, built for different jobs

Workyard is a construction-focused GPS time tracker with deep job costing. PunchPro is a full workforce management platform for hourly and field teams. Here is where each one wins.

Best construction-specific GPS

Workyard

Very precise GPS with automatic mileage and travel-time capture between job sites. A real strength if you bill or reimburse drive time.

Best overall workforce management platform

PunchPro

Time tracking, scheduling, PTO, approvals, GPS, and payroll exports in one plan — so growing teams run on a single platform instead of paying for gated tiers.

Best value for growing field service businesses

PunchPro

A flat base fee plus $7 per user — with everything included — against Workyard’s $50 base fee and $13-per-user Workforce Management tier. The gap widens as you grow.

Side by side

PunchPro vs Workyard at a glance

A feature-by-feature look at how the two platforms compare for growing businesses and field teams.

Feature	PunchPro	Workyard
Time Tracking	Included	Included
GPS Tracking	Included	Included — very precise
Mileage & Travel Time	Not included	Automatic
Employee Scheduling	Included	Higher-tier plan
PTO Management	Included	Higher-tier plan
Time Off Requests	Included	Higher-tier plan
Payroll Exports	Included	Yes
Payroll Flexibility	Provider-agnostic	Export & integrations
Job Tracking	Included	Included
Job Costing & Cost Codes	Unlimited cost codes, jobs & projects	Included — cost codes
Cost Dashboards & Reporting	Live dashboard + exportable reports	Downloadable reports
Department Tracking	Included	Limited
Multiple Pay Rates	Included	Yes
Overtime Rules	Included	Included
Approval Workflows	Included	Included
Mobile App	Mobile-first	Yes
Free Plan	Yes	No — 14-day trial
Base Fee	$39.99/mo (Growth)	$50/mo on every plan
Industry Focus	Field & service teams, multi-industry	Construction & trades
Workforce Management Features	Full platform, one plan	Split across plan tiers
Pricing Structure	Flat base + per user	$50 base + per-user tiers

Start Free Trial →

Feature breakdown

PunchPro vs Workyard Features

A closer look at how each platform handles the work growing teams care about most.

Time Tracking

Workyard

Workyard’s GPS time clock is accurate and field-tested, with offline mode, geofence-based clock-out rules, and a full audit trail on every time card. It’s built around construction crews moving between job sites.

PunchPro

PunchPro pairs accurate clock-in/clock-out with job and department context, overtime rules, and multiple pay rates — so tracked time flows straight into payroll-ready exports.

WinnerA close call on tracking itself — PunchPro when those hours need to drive scheduling, PTO, and payroll in the same plan.

GPS Tracking

Workyard

GPS is Workyard’s calling card: precise location capture, geofencing, and automatic mileage and travel-time tracking between sites. For construction companies that bill drive time, that depth is genuinely valuable.

PunchPro

GPS verification is part of PunchPro’s mobile clock-in, so you can confirm employees are on-site across multiple job locations — without paying a premium for it.

WinnerWorkyard for GPS depth, mileage, and travel time; PunchPro for straightforward on-site verification included in an affordable plan.

Scheduling

Workyard

Workyard offers drag-and-drop crew scheduling with job details and checklists — but it lives on the higher-priced Workforce Management plan, not the entry Time Tracking tier.

PunchPro

Employee scheduling is built into PunchPro alongside time tracking. Build shifts, assign jobs, and see scheduled vs. actual hours without moving up a tier.

WinnerPunchPro — scheduling and tracking in one platform, included rather than gated behind a higher plan.

PTO & Time Off

Workyard

Time-off policies, requests, and approvals are available in Workyard — but only on its Workforce Management plan, and holiday pay must be entered manually through a policy.

PunchPro

PTO management and time-off requests are included in PunchPro, so employees request time off and managers approve it in the same place they track hours.

WinnerPunchPro — PTO and time-off requests included alongside scheduling and time tracking, on every plan.

Job Costing

Workyard

Job costing is where Workyard shines. Every time entry ties to jobs and cost codes, labor costs update in real time, and reports break spend down by project, phase, and crew.

PunchPro

PunchPro is built for construction cost codes — create unlimited cost codes, jobs, and projects, tie labor costs to every hour, and see it all on a live cost dashboard with exportable, buildable reports.

WinnerPunchPro — unlimited cost codes, jobs, and projects with live cost dashboards and exportable reports, included in one plan rather than tiered.

Payroll Flexibility

Workyard

Workyard exports approved time cards and integrates with tools like QuickBooks, ADP, Gusto, and construction accounting systems — a solid set of connections for the trades.

PunchPro

PunchPro is payroll-provider agnostic. You do not switch payroll providers — approved hours, overtime, and pay rates export cleanly into your existing payroll process.

WinnerPunchPro — payroll-ready exports with no lock-in, designed around how field businesses actually run payroll.

Industry Fit

Workyard

Workyard is purpose-built for construction and the trades. That focus is a strength for GCs and subs — and a limitation for everyone else, since the workflows assume construction jobs and cost codes.

PunchPro

PunchPro serves hourly and field teams across construction, HVAC, plumbing, landscaping, cleaning, home services, and beyond — one platform that fits however your business grows.

WinnerWorkyard if you’re construction-only and want construction-only workflows; PunchPro for every other field and service business.

Mobile Experience

Workyard

Workyard’s mobile app is well regarded for clock-in/out and offline tracking, though some users note the web dashboards can feel dense and cluttered on smaller screens.

PunchPro

PunchPro is mobile-first by design. Crews clock in with GPS, view schedules, and request time off from their phones, while managers approve from anywhere.

WinnerPunchPro — a mobile-first experience built for crews working away from a desk, with a simpler learning curve.

Pricing & Value

Workyard

Every Workyard plan carries a $50 monthly base fee plus a per-user charge — $6/user for Time Tracking or $13/user for Workforce Management on annual billing (more month-to-month). There’s no free plan.

PunchPro

PunchPro’s Growth plan is $39.99 plus $7 per user with everything included — scheduling, PTO, approvals, GPS, and payroll exports — and there’s a free plan to get started.

WinnerPunchPro — lower base fee, lower per-user rate, and no feature gating between tiers.

See PunchPro on your own team

Time tracking, scheduling, PTO, and payroll exports in one platform.

Start Free Trial →

Pricing

PunchPro vs Workyard Pricing

Both platforms use a base fee plus per-user pricing — but Workyard’s base fee is higher, its per-user rate on the comparable plan is nearly double, and key features sit on its top tier.

PunchPro

Flat platform fee + per active user. Free plan to start.

Free$0 to get started

Growth$39.99/mo + $7 / user

Enterprise$99/mo + $12 / user

Workyard

$50/mo base fee on every plan + per user (billed annually). No free plan.

Time Tracking$50/mo + $6 / user

Workforce Management$50/mo + $13 / user

EnterpriseCustom contact sales

Team size	PunchPro Growth $39.99 + $7/user	Workyard Workforce Mgmt $50 + $13/user (annual)	What you get with PunchPro
10 employees	~$109.99/mo	~$180.00/mo	Scheduling, PTO, approvals, GPS, payroll exports — included
25 employees	~$214.99/mo	~$375.00/mo	Full workforce management, one platform
50 employees	~$389.99/mo	~$700.00/mo	Nearly half the cost, nothing gated
100 employees	~$739.99/mo	~$1,350.00/mo	PunchPro saves over $600/mo at scale

Estimates for comparison only. Workyard pricing shown at annual-billing rates; month-to-month rates are higher, and Workyard’s scheduling, PTO, and time-off approvals require its Workforce Management plan — which is why that tier is used for a like-for-like comparison. PunchPro’s flat base + per-user model includes scheduling, PTO, approvals, GPS, and payroll exports on the Growth plan.

Why teams choose PunchPro

One platform for your whole workforce

Everything growing field and service teams need to schedule, track, approve, and pay — without stitching tools together.

Everything in one planScheduling, PTO, approvals, GPS, and payroll exports — no tier gating.

Lower total cost$39.99 base + $7/user beats a $50 base + $13/user at every team size.

No payroll lock-inPayroll-provider agnostic — keep the payroll you already use.

Scheduling + time tracking togetherBuild shifts and track the hours they produce in one flow.

PTO management includedRequests and approvals where you already manage hours.

Mobile-first experienceCrews clock in with GPS and view schedules from their phones.

Built for more than constructionHVAC, plumbing, landscaping, cleaning, home services, and more.

Free plan to startTry PunchPro free — no 14-day countdown, no credit card.

Construction cost codes built inUnlimited cost codes, jobs, and projects — with cost dashboards and exportable reports.

An honest fit check

Which one is right for you?

Both platforms are strong. The right choice comes down to construction-specific depth versus complete workforce management value.

Workyard may be the better fit if…

Workyard is a capable construction workforce tool with real strengths in GPS and job costing.

You’re a construction or trades business, full stop
You’re deep in construction accounting systems like Sage 300 CRE or Foundation
You bill or reimburse mileage and travel time
Compliance forms at clock-in/out matter to you
You’re comfortable paying more for that depth

PunchPro may be the better fit if…

PunchPro is built for businesses that manage hourly teams and want everything in one affordable plan.

You manage hourly employees
Scheduling and PTO shouldn’t cost a tier upgrade
You want to keep your existing payroll provider
You want one platform instead of several tools
You want unlimited cost codes, jobs, and projects with labor costs by hour
You’re in construction, HVAC, plumbing, landscaping, cleaning, home services, or field ops
Predictable, lower pricing matters as you grow

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Quick answers to the most common PunchPro vs Workyard questions.

Is PunchPro a Workyard alternative?

Yes. PunchPro is a workforce management alternative to Workyard. While Workyard focuses on construction-specific GPS time tracking, PunchPro combines time tracking with employee scheduling, PTO management, GPS verification, job costing with unlimited cost codes and cost dashboards, approval workflows, and payroll exports in one platform built for growing field and service businesses across many industries.

Is Workyard free?

No. Workyard offers a 14-day free trial but no free plan. Paid plans combine a $50 monthly company base fee with a per-user charge. PunchPro offers a free plan to get started, with no credit card required.

Does PunchPro offer scheduling?

Yes. Employee scheduling is built into PunchPro alongside time tracking, so you can build shifts, assign jobs, and track the hours that result without juggling separate tools. In Workyard, scheduling is part of the higher-priced Workforce Management plan.

Does PunchPro offer GPS tracking?

Yes. PunchPro includes GPS tracking so you can verify where employees clock in and out across multiple job sites. Workyard also offers strong GPS tracking with mileage and travel-time capture, which is a genuine strength for construction crews.

Which platform is better for contractors?

Both serve contractors well. PunchPro is built for construction cost codes — create unlimited cost codes, jobs, and projects, tie labor costs to every hour, and track it all with live dashboards and exportable reports, alongside scheduling, PTO, approvals, GPS verification, and payroll exports at a lower total cost. Workyard’s edge is automatic mileage and travel-time tracking, which matters if you bill or reimburse drive time.

Which platform is better for field service companies outside construction?

PunchPro. Workyard is purpose-built for construction and the trades, while PunchPro is designed for hourly and field teams across many industries — cleaning, landscaping, HVAC, home services, staffing, and more — with scheduling, PTO, and payroll exports included.

Can PunchPro work with my payroll provider?

Yes. PunchPro is payroll-provider agnostic. You don’t need to switch payroll providers to use it. PunchPro produces payroll-ready exports of approved hours, overtime, and pay rates that work alongside your existing payroll process.

Why do businesses switch from Workyard?

The most common reasons are cost and plan gating. Workyard’s $50 monthly base fee plus per-user pricing adds up quickly, and scheduling, PTO, and time-off approvals sit on its higher Workforce Management tier. PunchPro includes scheduling, PTO, approvals, GPS, and payroll exports in one affordable plan, and it isn’t limited to construction.

Looking for an alternative to Workyard?

Track employee time, build schedules, manage PTO, approve hours, and simplify payroll from a single workforce management platform.

Start Free Trial →

No credit card required. Get started in minutes.